How Much Is a Ty Beanie Baby Silver the Gray Tabby Cat 1999 Worth?
Based on 1 independent scans and 45 recent sold comparables, a Ty Beanie Baby Silver the Gray Tabby Cat 1999 is typically worth around $12. Recent sold prices ranged from $2 to $62 with a median of $10.
Get a value for your specific condition in 30 seconds
More listings of this item
Images from current eBay listings of this item.
Sold Range
$2.00 – $61.99
45 recent sales
Sold Median
$9.99
Realistic sale price
Asking (Active)
$13.49
26 live listings
AI Estimate
$12.00
Avg of 1 scans
Market Insight
Live listings are running 35% above what items actually sell for — sellers are asking $13 but completed sales are landing closer to $10. Price in line with sold comps to move it.
Recent Sold Comparables
What this item has actually sold for, pulled from public completed listings.
| Title | Sold |
|---|---|
| TY Beanie Babies Cats Pounce Amber Zip Prance Silver Nip lot 6 Tags with covers | $29.50 |
| Ty Beanie Babies 6 Baby Cat Lot Blizzard Pounce Booties Mattie Scat Silver BB23A | $8.59 |
| Ty Purr Cat Plush 12" Kitten Gray Leopard Stuffed Animal 2002 Silver Eyes Bow | $19.79 |
| Silver the Cat - Ty Beanie Baby 1999, 5th gen., MWMT, OBO | $3.99 |
| Silver the Cat TY Beanie Baby | Mint Heart & Tush Tag | $5.57 |
| Ty Beanie Baby - SILVER the Gray Tabby Cat (8 Inch) MWCT Stuffed Animal Toy | $9.98 |
Get a Value for Your Specific Item
This page shows market data for Ty Beanie Baby Silver the Gray Tabby Cat 1999 in general. Your item's actual value depends on condition, completeness, and current demand — scan it to get a specific number.
1. Snap a Photo
Just point your phone at the item — no typing.
2. AI Identifies It
Maker, model, era, and condition assessed in seconds.
3. See Real Prices
Sold comps + asking range from eBay, Poshmark, Mercari, etc.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much is a Ty Beanie Baby Silver the Gray Tabby Cat 1999 worth?
Based on 45 recent sold listings, a Ty Beanie Baby Silver the Gray Tabby Cat 1999 typically sells for $2 to $62 with a median of $10. The exact value depends on condition, completeness, and current market demand. Run a fresh scan for instant pricing on your specific item.
Where do these prices come from?
Sold prices come from completed listings on eBay, Poshmark, Mercari, Facebook Marketplace, and Etsy — actual sales, not asking prices. Active asking prices are pulled from live listings. We re-aggregate this data continuously as new scans come in.
Why do listing prices differ from sold prices?
Sellers commonly list above what items realistically sell for. The gap between "asking" and "sold" is the most important number to look at — pricing in line with the sold median moves your item; pricing at the asking ceiling means it sits.
Aggregated from 1 independent AI scans and 45 recent completed listings across eBay, Poshmark, Mercari, Facebook Marketplace, and Etsy. Re-aggregated daily. Last refreshed June 8, 2026.
Get a Real Value for Your Ty Beanie Baby Silver the Gray Tabby Cat 1999
AI-powered valuation backed by real sold data. Plans start at $5/mo.
Start Scanning