Skip to content
Underpriced AIUnderpriced AI

Pricing and accuracy

Sold prices vs asking prices

Why your scan shows recently sold and currently listed separately, and which number to price against.

Every unlocked scan shows two sets of comparables. They look similar and they mean very different things.

Recently sold

Sold comparables are completed sales: what a buyer actually paid, with the real price attached and a link to the listing. Your suggested price is built on these, because a sale is proof that someone paid that amount.

Currently listed

Listed comparables are active listings with asking prices. Nobody has paid those numbers yet. Asking prices are often higher than what items really sell for, sometimes much higher, because sellers can list at any price and wait.

Why we show both

The gap between the two is useful information. When active listings are asking noticeably more than items are selling for, that gets flagged right on your result. It usually means the category is full of hopeful pricing, and undercutting the askers still leaves you above the real sold average.

Reading market saturation

Alongside the two comp lists you get a saturation view: how many are listed right now, how many sold recently, and the sell-through rate. Use it like this:

  1. High sell-through and few active listings: you can price toward the high end and wait.
  2. Low sell-through and a wall of active listings: price toward the low end if you want the money now.
  3. Somewhere in between: the suggested price is your safe default.

Pricing strategy in practice

  • Use the low price for quick sales in saturated markets.
  • Use the high price for rare items when you can be patient.
  • Read the sold comps themselves before pricing anything valuable. Condition, completeness, and variant all move the number, and you can see which of those the sold items had.

Checking the comps yourself

Sold comparables include clickable links, so you can open the actual sale and confirm it matches your item. That is the fastest sanity check when a price looks too good to be true, and it is worth doing on anything you are about to spend real money on.

Frequently asked questions

Why is my suggested price lower than the listings I see on eBay?
Because active listings show asking prices, not sales. Sellers can ask anything and wait. Your suggested price follows recent sold prices, which is what buyers actually paid. When asking prices run well above sold prices, the scan result flags that gap for you.
What does sell-through rate tell me?
It compares how many items sold recently against how many are listed right now. A high rate means demand is absorbing supply, so you can price higher and wait. A low rate means the market is saturated, so pricing near the low end sells faster.
Should I price at the low, suggested, or high number?
Use the low price for quick sales in saturated markets, the high price for rare items when you can be patient, and the suggested price when you are not sure. Check the market saturation indicator and the sold comps before you decide.

Try it on web or mobile

Your first scan is free, no card. Plans start at $5 a month and packs at $4 for 5 scans.

Updated 2026-09-05. Something wrong or missing? Tell us and we fix the guide, not just the reply.