Vintage Pyrex Butterprint (Amish) Value
1957-1968, turquoise-on-white farm motif. Based on 41 recent eBay sales, most Butterprint (Amish) pieces sell between $31 and $75, with a median of $40. Exceptional examples have brought up to $300.
Recent sold prices (41 sales)
Real eBay sold-listing data, refreshed 2026-07-11. Ranges reflect the mix of forms, conditions, and completeness actually selling — not asking prices.
Why the huge price spread?
The gap between $12 and $300 for the same butterprint (amish) listing comes down to form (a rare chip-and-dip or promotional piece beats a common bowl), completeness (full nesting sets bring 2 to 3x the sum of singles, and original lids matter), condition (dishwasher fading and utensil marks cut value hard), and the stamp (all-caps PYREX is vintage Corning; lowercase pyrex is modern with little collector value).
What is YOURS worth?
The ranges above cover the whole market. Your specific piece, with its exact form, condition, and completeness, has a much narrower real answer:
What's YOUR vintage Pyrex worth?
Snap or upload a photo of any Pyrex piece and our AI names the pattern instantly. Free, no account needed.
More vintage Pyrex values
- Pink Gooseberry · ~$79
- Lucky in Love · ~$29
- Snowflake · ~$30
- Friendship · ~$50
- Spring Blossom Green · ~$40
- Starburst · ~$26
- Atomic Eyes · ~$175
- Primary Colors Mixing Bowls · ~$90
- Pink Daisy · ~$65
Or start with the full Vintage Pyrex value guide.
Some links on this page are eBay affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.