How Much Is a Vintage Masonic Mark Penny / Personal Membership Token - Bay City Lodge No. 865 AF & AM (1941-1942) Worth?
If you are sourcing or selling a Vintage Masonic Mark Penny / Personal Membership Token - Bay City Lodge No. 865 AF & AM (1941-1942), expect around $14. Prices swing widely, anywhere from $5 to $99 depending on condition, edition, and demand. That is across a healthy sample of 93 completed sales.
What's YOUR item worth?
This page shows the market average. Snap or upload a photo of your item and our AI values it instantly. Free, no account needed.
More listings of this item
Images from current eBay listings of this item — tap a photo to view the listing.
Shop all current Vintage Masonic Mark Penny / Personal Membership Token - Bay City Lodge No. 865 AF & AM (1941-1942) listings on eBay →Sold Range
$4.99 – $99.00
93 recent sales
Sold Median
$14.00
Realistic sale price
Asking (Active)
$16.00
35 live listings
AI Estimate
$13.20
Avg of 1 scans
Market Insight
Asking and sold prices are aligned ($16 asking vs $14 sold median) — the market is settled and your sale price will track the median if condition + comps match.
Recent Sold Comparables
What this item has actually sold for, pulled from public sold listings.
Some links on this page are eBay affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Get a Value for Your Specific Item
This page shows market data for Vintage Masonic Mark Penny / Personal Membership Token - Bay City Lodge No. 865 AF & AM (1941-1942) in general. Your item's actual value depends on condition, completeness, and current demand — scan it to get a specific number.
1. Snap a Photo
Just point your phone at the item — no typing.
2. AI Identifies It
Maker, model, era, and condition assessed in seconds.
3. See Real Prices
Sold comps + asking range from eBay, Poshmark, Mercari, etc.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much is a Vintage Masonic Mark Penny / Personal Membership Token - Bay City Lodge No. 865 AF & AM (1941-1942) worth?
Based on 93 recent sold listings, a Vintage Masonic Mark Penny / Personal Membership Token - Bay City Lodge No. 865 AF & AM (1941-1942) typically sells for $5 to $99 with a median of $14. The exact value depends on condition, completeness, and current market demand. Run a fresh scan for instant pricing on your specific item.
Where do these prices come from?
Sold prices come from sold listings on eBay, Poshmark, Mercari, Facebook Marketplace, and Etsy — actual sales, not asking prices. Active asking prices are pulled from live listings. We re-aggregate this data continuously as new scans come in.
Why do listing prices differ from sold prices?
Sellers commonly list above what items realistically sell for. The gap between "asking" and "sold" is the most important number to look at — pricing in line with the sold median moves your item; pricing at the asking ceiling means it sits.
Other Collectibles Guides
Recent value guides for related items in the same category.
Based on 93 recent sold listings across eBay, Poshmark, and Mercari. Last updated August 8, 2026.
Get a Real Value for Your Vintage Masonic Mark Penny / Personal Membership Token - Bay City Lodge No. 865 AF & AM (1941-1942)
A 5-scan pack with real sold comps for your exact items and condition — just $4, no subscription. Want the subscription rate? Plans start at $5/mo.
Get 5 Scans for $4